The author pursues the question why some societies collapsed and others didnt. Next to each word, write n never seen it before, s seen it, but dont. Tragically, it was statue building that seems to have lead to easter island s collapse. Easter island geography easter island is a small, triangular piece of land situated in a remote part of the south pacific ocean. Strong cultural coverage gets under the skin of this skinny country including a special feature on wine. Jared diamond described in its bestseller collapse the reasons for this ecoside. Easter island, with an area of only 64 square miles, is the worlds most isolated scrap of habitable land. For me, jared s summary about easter island in his 2007 paper in science remains definitive for now. The population of easter island followed the same line. Jared diamond has asked the question, what were they thinking when they cut down the last palm tree. The big picture still looks like overexploitation, but when you get down into the details it does get messier, as not all the evidence marshalled to support the competing interpretations is strong enough to do so. How societies choose to fail or succeed, jared diamond. Easter island, a lesson for us all sustainable footprint. Diamond is professor of physiology at the university of cal.
For a tiny island of 64 square miles, with its nearest neighbours some 1,300 miles. You do not have access to the full text of this article, the first page of the pdf of this article appears above. Twentiethcentury discoveries of pollen prove that rapu nui had once been covered in palm forests, which had turned into grassland by the time the europeans arrived on the island. Theories, methods, and practice with colin renfrew. Physics and society education department of physics and. How societies choose to fail or succeed, is that colonists arrived on the island around 7001100 ce and thrived to the point that the islands population grew as high as 15,000. Sadly, this thesis was not challenged because it so conveniently confirmed 18 th century prejudice about superior european and inferior everyone. My main hope for my sons generation is that we may now choose to learn from the fates of societies like easters p. Adapted from jared diamond, easter s end, discover, august 1995, 168, pp. Diamonds thesis about what happened on easter island is not new, building as it did on presumptions originally offered by the first europeans to set foot on the island in the early 18 th century. The easter island ecocide theory put forward by diamond quickly became a widely promoted mantra, particularly among environmentalists, despite being challenged in the paper from genocide to ecocide.
This title features expanded coverage of patagonia, including new adventure options in puerto natales and more information on chiles crown jewel, torres del paine national park. The pacific ocean, the pitcairn islands, and easter island. By the time dutch explorersthe first europeans to reach the remote islandarrived on easter day in 1722, the land was nearly barren. Few places on earth are as well known for their socalled mysteries as easter island, also known as rapa nui. The mystery of easter island imagine arriving on a small island in the pacific ocean about halfway between the island of tahiti and the west coast of south america to find giant rock statues of humanlike figures greeting you along the coastline. This is what dutch sea captain jacob roggeveen found when he arrived there in 1722 on easter sunday. The fate of easter island can be a lesson for the modern world too.
His father, louis, was a distinguished paediatrician and expert on blood diseases, while his mother, flora kaplan. It lies in the pacific ocean more than 2,000 miles west of the nearest continent south america, 1,400. The mystery of easter island travel smithsonian magazine. Jared diamonds argument about the society of easter island is laid out in chapter 2 of this book. Their movement from quarry to erection site required so many trees for logs and rope making that deforestation was complete by 1400 to 1600 ad. The easter island ecocide never happened response to. The bronx journal septemberoctober 2002 b 8 rap a nui. Belonging to chile, it is located 2,237 miles west of that country, making it one of the most isolated inhabited islands in the world. Jared diamond, who used the easter island story as the lead case study in his 2005 book collapse, responds to the charge below. Among all such vanished civilizations, that of the former polynesian society on easter island remains unsurpassed in mystery and isolation. How societies choose to fail or succeed, viking, new york, 2005. The article describes the former abundance of trees and forests on easter island. I was there a few years ago and felt devastated by what i saw. A read is counted each time someone views a publication summary such as the title, abstract, and list of authors, clicks on a figure, or views or downloads the fulltext.
There has been much controversy and confusion concerning the origins of. The idea, popularized by scientist jared diamond in his book collapse. A companion to easter island a concise guide to the history, culture, and individual archaeological sites at rapa nui, p. Poor agricultural practices such as massive deforestation are the primary causes of resource depletion. An answer for an enduring question barzin pakandam abstract easter island is the most isolated inhabited spot on earth, devoid of heavy timber and most resources.
Easter island mystery revealed using mathematical model. The rape of rapa nui 2 soon after the publication of collapse. Lipo and hunt respond we are hardly surprised that jared diamond would write that we are transparently wrong about easter island. Ecological collapses of preindustrial societies the tanner.
His numerous publications include the archaeology of hollywood and archaeology. Is diamond correct in asserting that information from the past, both from. Diamond, jared the rise and fall of the third chimpanzee. Jared diamond tells us that unlike the easter islanders, we have histories of the pastinformation that can save us. Originally, there were many trees on easter island like other polynesian islands. Easter islands end by jared diamond originally published in discover magazine, 1995 i. Hunt last semester, and he used his easter island research to provide test cases and practical examples of the concepts we were going over. Admiral roggeveen, who came upon the island on easter day in 1722, named it easter island. Easter islands end by jared diamond, published in the discover magazine on august 1995, provides insight into how an increased population and rapid deforestation impair the sustainability of the environment. Using a vast historical and geographical perspective ranging from easter island and the maya to viking greenland and modern montana, diamond traces a. Jared diamond, the rise and fall of the third chimpanzee.
With lessons from the norse of iron age greenland, deforested easter island and presentday montana, jared diamond talks about the signs that collapse is near, and how if we see it in time. Among all such vanished civilizations that of the former polynesian society on easter island remain unsurpassed in mystery and isolation. The myths of easter island jared diamond responds mark lynas. Others, such as the societies of easter island and new zealands south. The pacific ocean, the pitcairn islands, and easter island 8485 the pitcairn islands 122 anasazi sites 142 maya sites 161 the viking expansion 182183 contemporary hispaniola 331 contemporary china 361 contemporary australia 386 political trouble spots of the modern world. Collapse how societies choose to fail or succeed jared. View homework help discussion questions jared diamond. Diamond believes that the polynesian settlers on rapa nui destroyed its forests, cutting down its trees for fuel and clearing land for 8 answer. The most prevalent beliefs are that easter island is treeless and the ancient people mysteriously vanished, leaving only the monolithic statues for europeans to find easterbrook. Diamond argues that the people of easter island essentially abused their environment.
Diamonds examination of easter island once again demonstrates that culture cannot survive without nature. Paper author barry peiser argues that diamonds significant. In the present volume, he focuses on elements which have led past societies to collapse and which continue to threaten our. About 400 year ago a complete deforestation on easter island lead to a collapse of the easter society. According to diamond, the easter islanders were so fixated with. Jared diamond, who used the easter island story as the lead case study in his. In 900, people from other island settled on easter island and they prospered. Today, the land, people and language are all referred to locally as rapa nui. This week i wrote a blog post reexamining the historical evidence for the view that what happened in prehistoric easter island is a classic story of ecological collapse and thereby holds lessons for us all. The world monuments fund on easter island opposite. The most recent concept to pervade public opinion about the island is that easter island is a metaphor for the end of the earth, associating the great moai. It lies in the pacific ocean more than 2,000 miles west of the nearest continent south america, 1,400 miles from even the nearest habitable island pitcairn. Responses should put ideas in your own words and should draw support both from the article and from your own knowledge and ideas. Restrained passion and conflicted loyalties drive this sweeping debut novel, in which two women of different eras experience the mysteries of easter island.
In his runaway bestseller guns, germs, and steel, jared diamond brilliantly examined the circumstances that allowed western civilizations to dominate much of the world. New evidence finds that easter island wasnt destroyed by. The meaning of easter island is that we must be aware of our impact on the environment, because once we destroy it we will be screwed. In 1995, unesco named easter island a world heritage site. He has a vested interest in defending his ecocide storyline published back in 1995 in discover magazine and again in his bestselling book collapse. Lonely planet chile and easter island country travel guide. Jared diamonds easters end imagining a sustainable. Different pathways of tikopia and easter island tikopia island and easter island are. It lies in the pacific ocean more than 2,000 miles west of the nearest continent south america. Jared diamond goes on to say, unlike the easter islanders, we have histories of the past information that can save us. The first polynesian colonists found themselves on an island with. I was convinced that this meant such a tragedy by the book collapse. Courtesy of jared diamond diamond came to his field from an odd angle. Yet, the first european travellers to the island marvelled at large.
He is pretty much one of three authoritative people studying rapa nui these days, and i can say from listening to him talk about it firsthand, the man knows his. The pacific ocean, the pitcairn islands, and easter island 8485 the pitcairn islands 122 anasazi sites 142 maya sites 161 the viking expansion 182183 contemporary hispaniola 331. Famous for its enigmatic statues and farflung location, easter island, and the mystery around its population collapse, has confounded researchers since captain cook and his crew visited it in 1774. Im particularly interested in books that will give me the sort of info id get if i went on a guided tour. Describe several factors that contributed to the extinction of trees on the island. Like easter island the earth has only limited resources to support human society and all its demands. Since then ive gotten to know jared diamond and mark lynas, so i wound up in the middle of their backandforth.
1044 689 1177 515 1180 64 952 570 316 617 288 487 31 296 1131 134 1172 188 28 1220 388 89 1318 6 11 1014 1107 1145 225 1403 146 865 176 1425 1058 1243